"McEntire's energy and enthusiasm seem to shed a new glow on the whole production. And of course the particular qualities of McEntire's lovely singing bring something fresh and exciting to Irving Berlin's score." - Variety "It's safe to place McEntire on the list of the finest replacements offered in recent seasons." - Broadway.com "Without qualification the best performance by an actress in a musical comedy this season. Ms. McEntire doesn't need a gun to bring Manhattan to its knees." - New York Times "She is waif-like cute. She is whimsical. She is eager. She is over-the-top funny. And her singing, substituting country character for Broadway belt, gives the old Berlin numbers a special piquancy." - New York Post "Amazingly, this is McEntire's Broadway debut — in fact, her first appearance in a play of any kind. After a long and fruitful career in Nashville, she suddenly makes Broadway her oyster." - New York Journal News (listed in order of appearance, character listed in bold) Buffalo Bill (Col. William F. Cody) - Conrad John Shuck
Frank Butler - Brent Barrett
Charlie Davenport - Peter Marx
Dolly Tate - Kerry O'Malley
Tommy Keeler - Eric Sciotto
Winnie Tate - Claci Miller
Mac, The Propman - Tom Schmid
Foster Wilson - Gerry Vichi
Chief Sitting Bull - Larry Storch
Annie Oakley - Reba McEntire
Jessie Oakley - Jenny Rose Baker
Nellie Oakley - Blaire Restaneo
Little Jake - Nicholas Jonas
Ballerina - Keri Lee
Hoop Dance Specialty - Adrienne Hurd
Running Derr - Tom Schmid
Eagle Feather - Carlos Lopez
Moonshine Lullaby Trio - Cleve Ashbury, Brian O'Brien, David Villella
Tap Dance - Brad Bradley
Pawnee Bill (Maj. Gordon Lillie) - Gerry Vichi
Messenger - Tom Schmidd
Band Leader - Marvin Laird
Mrs. Schyler Adams - Deanna Dys
Sylvia Potter-Porter - Dana Lynn Caruso
Ensemble - Cleve Asbury, Brad Bradley, Dana Lynn Caruso, Deanna Dys, David Eggers, Madeline Ehlert, Elisa Heinsohn, Hollie Howard, Adrienne Hurd, Keri Lee, Carlos Lopez, Brian O'Brien, Rommy Sandhu, Tom Schmid, Kelli Bond Severson, David Villella, Kent Zimmerman
